Sunday, July 21, 2019

What will replace secondary schools?


Ka pū te ruha ka hao te rangatahi

What will replace secondary schools?

We've long past the time when we can still be asking if secondary schools need to change.

"There's no longer a good fit between the education we are currently providing and the education we need" MOE 2012! As well, we need only to look at the transformational change that is sweeping through every industry and profession at an accelerating rate (music production, newspaper and the media, health care, public transport, private transport, retail, finance and banking, service provision etc). Why would we think secondary schooling will be bypassed?

As well, we have no excuse to be unaware of what skills seem increasingly necessary for people to thrive in not only the working world, but the world itself.
This graphic shows the top 10 skills important in the workforce. While the two groupings are quite similar, which you would expect as they are only 5 years apart, it’s interesting to note that Complex Problem Solving remains at the top but big movers are Critical Thinking from 4th to 2nd and Creativity from 10th to 3rd. And new entrants on the list are Emotional Intelligence racing into 6th and Cognitive Flexibility moving onto the list at 10th.

Are our schools consciously developing these skills within our learners or are we still putting all of our eggs in one basket - academic qualifications?

I've been hugely motivated by Valerie Hanon's book, Thrive, which sets out a blueprint for how secondary schools could adapt and respond to the pressures for change. Her vision for schools is to have a vision which focuses on students learning to thrive in a transforming world.

Students need to be able to thrive at 4 levels:
Thrive as a planet
Our young people need to know how to live sustainably, how to protect earth's biodiversity and to develop respect for and empathy of other cultures. This needs to be at the centre of our curriculum.

Thrive at societal level
She notes that in the most equitable countries of the world there is a higher level of thriving. Our young people need to be equipped to navigate in a fast changing job landscape, to learn and unlearn, and they must love learning. How can democratic values and values of equity be explored in our schools

Thrive at interpersonal level
Schools need to be places where young people can explore how to have and create great relationships. Schools must create learning environments where young people can develop respectful and caring relationships.

Thrive at intrapersonal level
Schools need to create environments where young people can discover who they are. Students must be able to explore their identity, find personal meaning and be valued for whom they are.

What will replace secondary schools?
Right now I'm thinking we could start with a vision similar to:
Learn to thrive in a transforming world
and then develop a curriculum focusing on the 4 levels of Thrive outlined above.

My view of what secondary schools of the future need to concentrate on is as follows:

  • Secondary schools must place student well-being at front and centre of every thing they do
    • This means the end of billboards skiting about achievement and attendance rates (imagine how this feels for those students who, despite their best efforts, can't achieve or attend at that level who see that reminder every day)
    • This means the end to archaic rules and punishments, including those in relation to personal appearance
    • This means an end to assessment and homework practices that detract from deep learning and lead to distress
  • Secondary schools of the future must reject being institutions of measurement and embrace being institutions of engagement and deep learning
  • Secondary schools of the future must embrace new definitions of success for them as an institution, for their staff and for their students.
    • Ask parents to describe the graduate they want from your school! Their answers won’t surprise you. Does your school really focus on these things? How much does the front half of the NZC feature in how your school goes about its business and considers its effectiveness?
  • Secondary schools of the future will invite students to be partners in the learning design process.
    • Own the important bits of content, knowledge, concepts and skills of your specialist subject but relinquish control over the context for the learning to occur in and even how students might evidence their understanding.

At Hobsonville Point Secondary School we're trying to explore these ideas. Our foundation principles of:
  • personalised learning
  • powerful partnerships
  • deep challenge and inquiry
are driving our practices in these areas.

Our focus at the moment is on exploring different definitions of success which has resulted in the work we are doing on developing a graduate profile. The current prototype has our school values of innovation, inquiry, collaboration and connectedness as the key elements of this graduate profile. Sally gives a full description of this work in the last section of her latest post

We're looking forward to discussing this work with ERO in Week 8.


7 comments:

Morgan Ngata said...

Kia ora Maurie,
Great blog! Thanks for sharing your provocative thinking. Our rangatahi have much to gain from these vital thoughts. I wish to address something I noticed recently in this blog and at a recent presentation on Deep Learning. When we begin to consider models of education/thinking from overseas we connect with these concepts and see their value BUT fall short of connecting these concepts to an essential piece of our unique country without realising the potential that awaits… this being Te Tiriti o Waitangi (The Treaty of Waitangi.)

I have taken the liberty to provide some possible answers that I would feel are essential to consider in any school that is serious about thriving in a future Aotearoa.

Thrive as a planet: This needs to be at the centre of our curriculum.
Explicitly focusing on Te Tiriti o Waitangi is essential for us as citizens of Aotearoa to come together in a way that is truly sustainable for both the hauora of our environment (therefore our economy) and our cultures. This could potentially provide a much needed (intercultural) model for other countries to use as well.
Thrive at a societal level: How can democratic values and values of equity be explored in our schools?
Sharing a vision and relentlessly pursuing a society that is based on authentic Partnership, Protection and Participation of Te Tiriti o Waitangi is a responsibility as well as a privilege. New Zealand educators need to focus more on the current imbalance of power and how this can be corrected through equity and empathy AND action. This links to something I read recently…”Knowledge moves from your head to your heart through your hands…” Te Tiriti o Waitangi is a unique, culturally authentic context that can lead towards deep learning outcomes for our rangatahi and others that have a significant impact on individuals, whanau, communities and our nation.

Thrive at interpersonal level: Schools must create learning environments where young people can develop respectful and caring relationships.
Reread the answers to questions 1 and 2.

Thrive at intrapersonal level: Students must be able to explore their identity, find personal meaning and be valued for whom they are.
Te Tiriti o Waitangi is the basis for our countries future success and I see it as potentially a powerful enabler for further equity and social justice globally. Let's begin to reframe this important document so that our identity is one to be championed. We got a glimpse of how the world responded to the power of Aroha in response to terror… Lets ensure we lead the world in other acts of kindness and courage.

What will replace secondary schools?
Right now I'm thinking we could start with a vision similar to:
Learn to thrive in a transforming world through realising the potential of te Tiriti o Waitangi.
and then develop a curriculum focusing on the 4 levels of Thrive outlined above.

Bec KauKau said...

Kia ora! I enjoyed reading this and appreciate your unapologetic rejection of practices that don't promote student wellbeing, e.g., skiting billboards and uniform violations. As an intermediate school principal, I'm keen to see how our NZ secondary schools will navigate current curriculum and assessment expectations with emerging research that urges us all to go beyond / away / deeper / etc. I hope your ERO reviews demonstrate key 21st century skills, specifically active listening, when hearing engaging in your journey to date and vision for the future.

Anwar Barde said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Vishal Sharma said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
kavita said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Vishal Sharma said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Asad said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.